What is the basis of truth and judgment if God does not exist? Can there be ultimate truth if there is not an ultimate authority on what is true? If human beings are the most advanced being in existence, are we the closest thing to that “ultimate authority”? If so, which of us decides what is true and what is false? Is it the person with the highest IQ? Is it the majority or the most impressive minority? Given human weakness seen in errors, mistakes, and self-deception, can we trust the authorities we elect? Can we trust that election in the first place?
Nihilism is the only honest end of atheism. An atheist who claims that there is meaning in life, in existence, is avoiding the ultimate end of their arguments – there is no meaning or purpose to life. We simply exist. We come from natural means and we go into nothingness and nothing inbetween matters. The defense of life, rights, and “good” are foolishness unless one rejects humans as the ultimate authority on what is truth.
If truth remains subjective, relative, and bound to human definition it will remain an ever-shifting thing and therefore empty of any true meaning. Truth will become as valuable as gold. Gold is just a shiny metal. We say it has value so it has value. What is the difference between flowers and weeds? Only definition. We value flowers and we despise weeds. They are colorful plants with a pleasant scent – big deal. To some the difference between flowers and weeds would be a big deal. But if humans are the ultimate authority who is to say which stance is correct?
The sun exists. Nobody (credible) would deny the existence of the sun. But this truth is empty of value. When it comes to values, it is all a matter of opinion unless there is an ultimate opinion to appeal to. Otherwise we can all argue until we die and it will not matter. It will not even qualify as wasted time as all time is a waste – nothing you do will change anything or truly matter…unless God exists.
On what basis does the atheist judge? His/her own judgment? Laughable. By their own arguments I can disregard what they say. If they are right, my ignorance is empty of detriment. I will still die and become nothing. My ignorance might even make me happier as I will continue to live believing what I do has meaning.
And so I laugh at those who turn up their noses at “those ignorant zealouts” because their own beliefs prove that they are fools. It is empty. Why are you angry? If you are right then Christians, Muslims, etc can say whatever they want and nothing will come of it. Why argue with them? It changes nothing. If you enjoy feeling superior and exhibiting your intelligence try exercising some restraint and simply ignore their meaningless prattle. You are going to die, they are going to die, everyone is going to die – and then nothing.
So shut up or get religion.